One-man band or solo entertainer
Dear Musicians,
While one-man bands where very popular at some point, they seem to be much less in demand on cruise lines nowadays. It seems as though solo entertainers have replaced many of the one-man bands for various reasons.
One big area of confusion, however, seems to be the definitions of both entertainers. The most important difference, in our view, is that one-man bands tend to use sequences heavily to support their singing, while solo entertainers focus on their vocal and instrumental performance and may add light sequences if at all.
Cruise lines simply tend to stay away from entertainers that use sequences heavily. We understand that good one-man bands take the time to collect sounds that effectively make you sound like a full band. However, many of their counterparts use cheap midi-sounding instruments because it costs less money and effort which is now hurting their chances to land a gig on a cruise ship.
Solo entertainers, guitarists or pianists that entertain either with our without vocals, simply show more talent and are often considered a more valuable product. If you consider that a lot of cruise lines now offer karaoke bars where passengers can entertain themselves, it’s important not to present an entertainer that merely pushes the start button on his off-the-shelf sequencer and sings along which may in the end come across as a version of karaoke.
This post has 6 comments
August 12th, 2008
Hi Marco – I’m glad to hear this. What do you think is driving this change? Are audiences tired of recording accompaniment? Or have they always hated it and cruise lines are finally agreeing? Why the sudden change?
August 16th, 2008
Dave, I don’t think this change was all that sudden. This has been like this for quite some time now. My personal opinion is that most of the blame lies with those musicians that don’t like to make the extra effort to present something that sounds great. We get so many demos of guys that use the general midi sounds that come with even the cheapest keyboards.
I guess minimum efforts are no longer enough to land a gig on a cruise ship.
August 17th, 2008
That’s also great news.
September 17th, 2008
I am not sure what cruise lines you are refering to but I really do not think the solos or one man bands using tracks are on the way out at all. You are seeing just the opposite of what I see and I have years of experience on ships. Actually, with the popularity of acoustic oriented acts such as Jack Johnson, John Mayer and acoustic music in general, the ships are now accepting acoustic solos without tracks as well as solos with tracks.
I totally agree it’s the lazy hacks you speak of that should be eliminated and that tracks should never take the place of live musicians. But not all one man bands are lazy hacks no more than all musicians are drug addicts, lazy bums or alcoholics. And I do not like other musicians assuming that anymore than I should assume they have a bad ear, play out of time and wet the bed just because I know a musician like that.
I can speak on this “One Man Band” subject with much experience and authority. I have been a full timer for 30 years. I play guitar, bass, some keyboard and sing. I have played in bands of all styles, types and sizes. I have backed major recording artists and traveled abroad. It was the economy, tougher DUI laws and the acceptance of DJ’s that forced many full timers like me to downsize in order to survive. I went from a full time 5 piece band, to a 4, a 3, a duo, to just a solo over the years simply trying to pay my bills.
It wasn’t my choice that the live music scene took a dive. Uninformed people have it backwards. The solos with or without tracks didn’t put the bands out of work. The lack of budget due to numerous reasons forced the bands to downsize using MIDI, or anything else to get a full band sound, in order to survive.
As a solo I first played acoustic and electric only, then with a drum machine. Later added bass pedals and eventually went full MIDI in the 80′s. Granted the early MIDI tracks sounded phony to a good ear, but with the advance in digital technology, new sound modules and a skilled MIDI savvy musician, the tracks can sound so real that many musicians can’t tell the difference on a recording. Do you realize how many movies, TV commercials etc. use MIDI for their music?
What I see happening now is so many bad singers and musicians are riding on the backs of MIDI files and Karaoke tracks like a clumsy kid riding a bike with training wheels. And since they have little musical ability, and do not have a good ear, they use cheap sound sources for the MIDI files and have no ear or editing skills to make them sound realistic. They somehow get hired. And just who does the hiring I ask?
When I work as a one man band I have to play my guitar and sing just as hard if not harder than when I play in a 5 piece band. Not only do I have to learn my guitar parts and the vocal, I have to learn the bass, drums and keyboard parts when I program my MIDI sequences. So how is that so easy and lame compared to playing just your instrument and/or singing as a solo I ask? It’s ironic that so many of the show band musicians look down their nose at the solos actually singing and playing using tracks, when in fact, they are pretending to play while the actual sound you hear in the showroom is a recorded track and usually not even of themselves playing.
Oh, and I have heard some great tracks made by using various software recording programs and by recording actual drums and bass etc. as opposed to MIDI etc. but, I have also heard some really crappy tracks made that way as well. So don’t blame it on the MIDI musicians alone. MIDI has drastically improved since the 80′s my friend as have all things electronic. I know as I was there at the very start of MIDI. Look at computers of the 70′s compared to now!
Bottom line is whoever hires the so called one man bands or musicians needs to screen the applicants better. And those who whine about the lame one man bands shouldn’t assume they are all lame. Don’t decide just because you tried a slice of pizza, and it tastes bad, that all pizza is bad. I would love nothing more than to play in a full time 4-5 piece band. It just isn’t economically possible in many areas these days. How do you think the big bands of the 40′s felt when the smaller combos started becoming the norm in the night clubs? Read the history books. It was terrible! Hundreds of musicians were out of work. Times change and we have to adjust.
I have been told by several ships music directors and cruise directors that the show bands would be eliminated long before the one man bands or solos. I hope and pray that never happens. I want all qualified musicians to have a good gig and I think the cruise ship industry will be smart to keep as many live musicians and entertainers working as possible. The guests want to be entertained!
There is need and room for all types and sizes of good bands including good solos with or without MIDI tracks. Those who go out and shake the trees and bushes find that work. Those who don’t just sit home and piss and moan about those who do find work. Music is a cruel and tough business. If you love it you will find a way. If not then best get one of those so called “Real Jobs” and leave music to those who can hack it. Bottom line is I can entertain with or without tracks so I am good to go either way. I’ll let the audience decide. Jam on!
July 21st, 2010
I agree with Deano. A lot of us one-man band MIDI guys go out of our way to get it as good as we can. This means lots of time and money tweaking the sequences or picking up samples or soft-synths to take things up a notch sound-wise. The only time I use general MIDI is when I’m checking out a MIDI file from the web. I even invested in TC Helicon’s Voiceworks to add harmonies. Settings in the Voiceworks are changed via CC messages when the sequence is playing, in order to change the harmony intervals to match chord changes. Doing MIDI based one-man band stuff is truly an art from when done to its maximum potential.
July 21st, 2010
dyonisos,
I was merely trying to make the distinction between those that use the simplest midi-setups (which sound horrible) compared to those that spend time to customize and update theirs.
We have many bands and solo entertainers on ships currently that have done exactly this.
I have commented on this many times in the forum and on this blog.
Add a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.